Last week, we had an intense discussion of the nominating process of the online comics categories of the NCS's Divisional Awards. The arguments became circular very quickly, and at the end, I didn't understand it any more clearly than I did when the thread started. And I really wanted to understand it better.
One of my main concerns was always been the committee of six. It has always been presented as a mechanicism to vet the professionalism of webcartoonists and suggest un-submitted cartoonists whose work should be considered. And that first part always rubbed me the wrong way.
So I went to someone who I felt could accurately shed some light on the topic -- one of the members of the NCS's "committee of six" for the past two years, Gary Tyrrell, who writes the webcomics news blog, Fleen.com.
That interview is below.
Log in to read the entire post.